unconstitutional

The State Will Fight: Files a Motion to Dismiss Growler Suit

The Office of the Attorney General, on behalf of Defendants Lawson and Spicola (DBPR and ABT), filed its Motion to Dismiss the “growler lawsuit” this morning.  The incorporated memorandum of law in support of the motion generally lays out a history lesson of how the statute was originally enacted, provides some red herring arguments in support of dismissing the lawsuit and includes a semi-hilarious explanation of why the container size law is “rational.”

As discussed in a previous post, the defendants here must only prove that the challenged law is rationally related to a legitimate government interest. It is the most lenient standard for judicial review available. Plaintiff has the burden of proving that the law serves no conceivable legitimate purpose.

Defendants mostly skirt the issue of rationality. They do bring it up briefly on three separate occasions. They argue, for example, that “iven that consumers are significantly more likely to attempt […]

By |November 19th, 2014|Blog|1 Comment

How Much Beer is Too Much? Florida Law says 64 Ounces is Too Much. 128 Ounces is Not?

craft-beer-week-new-york-city-photo-ccWhile small breweries around the country were providing consumers with new tastes and quality beer, Florida lagged behind.  Just as Florida lagged behind in the craft brew craze, Florida’s laws lag behind the rest of the country as Florida’s craft beer industry is burgeoning.  Specifically, Florida’s craft breweries can fill its consumers’ 32 ounce (1 quart) and 128 ounce (1 gallon) growlers ((A growler is a refillable container or jug into which tap beer is poured for home consumption.)), but any sizes in between are illegal.  That includes, of course, the 64 ounce growler, which also happens to be the industry’s standard size. ((The 64 ounce growler is also illegal in Utah.))

During Florida’s recently completed legislative session, a bill was introduced that would have legalized the 64 ounce growler.  The bill died in the Business & Professional Regulation Subcommittee.  Why?  (Lobbyists/Special Interests). […]

By |July 10th, 2013|Blog|Comments Off on How Much Beer is Too Much? Florida Law says 64 Ounces is Too Much. 128 Ounces is Not?